Review: Road House (2024) – A Struggle to Recapture the Original’s Magic

This Ain’t Your Father’s Road House and That’s Not a Good Thing

First of all. I’ve heard so many ask the question, “Is Road House 2024 a remake?” Yes, but it is a pretty big departure, too. Keep reading and I’ll break it down for you.

In the pantheon of action cinema, the 1989 classic Road House stands tall as a beacon of masculine film-making, with Patrick Swayze’s magnetic performance as Dalton becoming iconic. The 2024 remake, spearheaded by Amazon Studios (yes, them), plunges into this legendary narrative, emerging as a decent action flick in an era where the genre often feels diluted. Despite its modern polish and high-octane sequences, it falls short of recapturing the nuanced charm of its predecessor.

Jake Gyllenhaal steps into the shoes of Dalton, bringing commendable energy and intensity to the role. His portrayal, while engaging, lacks the layered complexity that Swayze infused into the original character. The remake reimagines Dalton as an Ex-UFC fighter whose tranquility masks a simmering rage, a stark departure from the philosophical bouncer with a psychology degree that defined the 1989 film. This shift strips away the intriguing psychological depth that was central to Dalton’s character, reducing him to a more conventional action hero archetype.

The fight scenes, choreographed with gritty realism, stand out as a highlight. Gyllenhaal and real-world UFC star Conor McGregor, making an impressive cinematic foray, deliver physically demanding performances that lend authenticity to the brawls. However, these well-executed sequences can’t compensate for the narrative and thematic voids left by the film’s reductive approach to its protagonist’s backstory and motivations.

Notably absent from the remake are pivotal characters like Wade Garrett, Dalton’s wise mentor, and Elizabeth Clay, his love interest, whose relationships with Dalton added emotional heft to the original storyline. Their exclusion in the 2024 version leaves a palpable gap, further diluting the remake’s connection to its source material.

Another odd absence (change?) is the name of the bar. Road House is also the name of the bar… Yep. That’s right. Instead of the Double Deuce, I guess they decided to lazily call the bar the same name as the film. Odd.

The cinematography of the fight scenes deserves praise for its visceral impact, capturing the brutality and immediacy of physical confrontation with a raw, unfiltered lens. These moments are immersive and convincingly executed, showcasing the film’s technical prowess and attention to the visceral aesthetics of combat.

However, the film’s casting and character dynamics hint at an underlying agenda, with a conspicuous emphasis on diversity that feels more like a checkbox exercise than a genuine narrative necessity. This approach, reflective of a broader trend in Hollywood, detracts from the storytelling authenticity and has led to mixed reactions among fans of the original film.

Considering Amazon Studios’ controversial handling of other beloved properties, such as The Lord of the Rings, the creative decisions in Road House align with a pattern of prioritizing modern sensibilities and forced diversity over faithful adaptation. This strategy, while (maybe) appealing to new audiences, risks alienating die-hard fans who cherish the original’s raw, unapologetic spirit.

In conclusion, the Road House remake is a serviceable action movie that manages to entertain but ultimately fails to capture the soul of the 1989 classic. While Gyllenhaal and McGregor deliver commendable performances, the film’s departure from the original’s philosophical underpinnings and character complexities leaves a lingering sense of missed opportunity.

In its bid to adapt and modernize, the remake loses sight of the unique qualities that made Road House a beloved cult classic, underscoring the challenging balance between honoring legacy and embracing contemporary trends in cinema.

Road House ’24 is a good popcorn flick. ‘Okay’ remake. Nothing special.

Have you seen either Road House movie? Let us know your thoughts below.

See more of our reviews.

See an explanation of our review rating scores.